Can the police sieze your belongings and hold it without charging you with a crime?

Civil asset forfeiture is a legal process that allows law enforcement agencies in Michigan to seize property they suspect is connected to criminal activity, even if the owner hasn’t been charged with a crime. This practice has been controversial, leading to significant reforms in recent years.​

Key Points:

News Article links

• Definition: Civil asset forfeiture permits authorities to confiscate assets believed to be involved in or resulting from criminal conduct without necessarily charging the owner.​Mackinac Center
• Reforms: Michigan has implemented several reforms to address concerns about civil asset forfeiture:​Mackinac Center
• 2015: Increased the standard of evidence required for forfeiture from “preponderance of evidence” to “clear and convincing evidence.” ​Mackinac Center
• 2016: Eliminated the requirement for property owners to post a bond before challenging a seizure. ​Mackinac Center
• 2019: Mandated a criminal conviction or plea agreement before forfeiting property valued under $50,000 in drug-related cases. ​AP News
• 2022: Amended laws to allow forfeiture of assets over $20,000 at airports without a criminal conviction. ​Mackinac Center
• Recent Developments: In 2023, a federal court ruled that Wayne County’s vehicle seizure program violated constitutional due process rights, highlighting ongoing concerns about forfeiture practices. ​Mackinac Center
• Statistics: In 2022, Michigan law enforcement agencies seized over $10.2 million in cash and conducted nearly 4,000 forfeitures. Notably, more than 150 individuals lost property without being charged, and another 100 without a conviction. ​Mackinac Center
• Criticism: Critics argue that civil asset forfeiture can lead to abuses, disproportionately affecting innocent individuals and marginalized communities. 
• Advocacy for Change: Organizations like the Mackinac Center for Public Policy advocate for ending civil asset forfeiture, suggesting that property should only be forfeited following a criminal conviction to better protect citizens’ rights. ​Mackinac Center

Understanding Michigan’s civil asset forfeiture laws is crucial, as they directly impact property rights and law enforcement practices. While reforms have been made, ongoing debates suggest that further changes may be necessary to ensure fairness and protect citizens’ rights

Can the police sieze your belongings and hold it without charging you with a crime?

Forfeiture laws in Michigan allow the government to seize property – like cash, cars, or even houses – if they believe it was involved in a crime.  This can happen even if the owner hasn’t been convicted of a crime. It’s a complex area of law with some important things to understand. 

What is Forfeiture?

Forfeiture is a legal process where the government takes ownership of private property because it’s believed to be connected to illegal activity. There are two main types:  

Criminal Forfeiture: This happens after someone has been convicted of a crime. The property seized is usually related to that specific crime. 

Civil Forfeiture: This can occur without a criminal conviction. The government argues that the property itself was involved in a crime, regardless of whether the owner is found guilty.  

Important Points to Know:

What Property Can Be Forfeited?

Under Michigan law (specifically related to drug crimes, (MCL 333.7521), a wide range of property can be seized, including:

• Money, negotiable instruments, and securities.
• Real estate (MCL 600.3815)
• Vehicles, boats, and aircraft (S.B. 2 & H.B 4001-4002)
• Equipment and materials used in illegal activities (like drug manufacturing).
• Anything of value exchanged for illegal substances.

How Does it Work?

Seizure: Law enforcement can seize property if they have probable cause to believe it’s connected to a crime. In some cases, they need a warrant, but not always (MCL 333.7522). 

Notice: If your property is seized, the government is supposed to notify you (MCL 600.4707 & 333.7523). If they can’t find you, they may publish a notice online or in a newspaper.  

Claim: If you want your property back, you usually have a limited time (e.g., 20-28 days after notice) to file a claim with the government, stating your interest in the property and why it shouldn’t be forfeited. This claim often needs to be written, signed, and verified (notarized).  

Civil Action: If you file a claim, the government (usually the Attorney General or local prosecutor) may then file a civil lawsuit in court to try and get a forfeiture order.

Burden of Proof: In a forfeiture hearing, the government generally has to prove by a “preponderance of the evidence” (meaning it’s more likely than not) that the property was connected to a crime (MCL 600.4707). However, for property valued over $50,000 in drug cases, the burden might shift to the owner to prove they didn’t know about the illegal activity (according to some interpretations of MCL 333.7523a).  

Conviction Requirement (Limited): A significant reform in 2019 (Senate Bill 2 and House Bills 4001 & 4002) requires a criminal conviction or plea agreement for forfeitures of property valued under $50,000 in drug-related cases, unless the owner abandons the property (news from May 2019).  

Rights of Property Owners

You have the right to:

• Be notified about the forfeiture proceedings.
• File a claim to contest the forfeiture.
• Have a hearing in court (if you file a claim).
• Present evidence to show your property wasn’t involved in a crime or that you were an innocent owner.

What Happens to Forfeited Property?

Generally, the law enforcement agency that seized the property can keep it for their use or sell it.

The proceeds from the sale are often used for law enforcement purposes (MCL 333.7524).

Kelsey’s Law Connection: It’s important not to confuse forfeiture laws with traffic laws like Kelsey’s Law (related to teen drivers and cell phone use). They are completely different areas of law.

Links to Laws:

• MCL 333.7521 (Controlled Substances – Forfeiture): You can find these sections within the Michigan Public Health Code on the Michigan Legislature website.
• MCL 600.4701 (Revised Judicature Act – Forfeiture): This act also contains provisions related to forfeiture.

Recent News:

• Michigan Supreme Court Ruling (July 2024): The Michigan Supreme Court ruled against Detroit’s practice of seizing cars in drug-related cases unless there’s evidence the car was used to transport drugs for trafficking purposes. This decision is seen as a curb on aggressive forfeiture practices.  
• Report on Forfeiture (October 2023): A report highlighted that even with recent reforms, Michigan still sees cases where people lose property without being charged with a crime, and most forfeiture cases happen without much court oversight (Mackinac Center, October 2023). 
• Limitations on Forfeiture Without Conviction (2019): As mentioned earlier, laws were passed in 2019 requiring a conviction in many drug-related forfeiture cases involving property under $50,000 (Michigan.gov press release, May 2019).

It’s crucial to understand that forfeiture laws can have a significant impact on individuals, even those who haven’t been found guilty of a crime. If your property has been seized, it’s highly recommended to seek legal advice immediately to understand your rights and options.