You go girl!!!
A public high school was found to have violated the First Amendment when it suspended a student from her cheerleading team for using profane speech off campus.
Mahanoy Area Sch Dist v BL, No 20-255, ___ US ___ (June 23, 2021).
The U.S. Supreme Court has determined that Pennsylvania high school officials did not possess the jurisdiction to reprimand a student for her off-campus, profane Snapchat post, which was made out of frustration after not being selected for the varsity cheerleading squad.
The court ruled 8-1 that the social media post did not cause a substantial disruption under Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District.
A female student at Mahanoy Area High School in Pennsylvania, who did not make the school’s varsity cheerleading team but was instead placed on the junior varsity team, expressed her frustration by posting two images on Snapchat while at a local store during the weekend.
One image included explicit language and gestures alongside general comments about cheerleading and school, although it did not specify the school by name.
The second image only contained the following text: “Love how me and [another student] get told we need a year of jv before we make varsity but tha[t] doesn’t matter to anyone else?”
The cheerleading coach and school administrators were made aware of B.L.’s posts and subsequently decided to suspend her from the team for a duration of one year.
Through her parents, Levy sued in federal court, asserting that the disciplinary action violated her First Amendment right to free speech. Additionally, they contended that it was the responsibility of her parents, not school officials, to administer discipline.
A federal district court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit both ruled in favor of Levy, stating that the Tinker substantial disruption standard does not apply to off-campus, online student speech.
Alternatively, the 3rd Circuit also determined that, even if Tinker was deemed applicable, the post did not reach the threshold of causing substantial disruption.
The school district wasted tax dollars and appealed the Supreme Court decision.
Justice Stephen Breyer Reasoning that a school’s regulatory interests are diminished when a student partakes in off-campus social media speech, it was identified that three distinct features of social media speech govern such an approach.
- With regard to off-campus speech by students, school officials rarely stand in loco parentis. “Geographically speaking, off-campus speech will normally fall within the zone of parental, rather than school-related, responsibility.”
- Courts should be skeptical of school officials’ regulatory interest in policing student social media speech, given that such speech could take place anytime during a 24-hour day.
- Schools have an interest in protecting even unpopular student speech, because “America’s public schools are the nurseries of democracy.”
He emphasized the importance of officials maintaining regulatory oversight over social media speech involving cyberbullying, harassment, threats, or breaches of school security devices.
Justice Alito’s concurring opinion advises public schools to exercise thoughtful caution when seeking to regulate off-campus speech.
Related Articles
A visit with a kick
POW - Right in the Kisser. Businesses watch out for the lawA Pennsylvania-based convenience store chain was hit with a lawsuit by the Biden administration at the same time the president stopped by one of their locations on the campaign trail. Sheetz is being accused...
Woman tried to board flight with 56 pounds of marijuana
Woman allowed airport police to check her luggage, had name tag on bags, according to reportsBefore a 21-year-old Memphis woman could board an United Airlines flight, Memphis International Airport Police found 56 pounds of marijuana in her luggage, according to...
Oregon governor signs a bill recriminalizing drug possession
Oregon governor signs a bill recriminalizing drug possession into lawOn April 1, 2024, Oregon Governor Tina Kotek signed House Bill 4002 into law, effectively recriminalizing the possession of small amounts of certain controlled substances. This legislation marks a...
John Sinclair, the inspiration for Ann Arbor’s Hash Bash, dead at 82
John Sinclair, the poet whose imprisonment for marijuana inspired the start of Ann Arbor’s long-running annual Hash Bash in the 1970s, has died. He was 82.Sinclair's passing occurred on Tuesday, April 2, 2024, at a Detroit hospital, merely four days prior to his...
More Posts
![Laws passed by Michigan lawmakers in 2023 will take effect](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Tea-just-drink-it.jpg)
Laws passed by Michigan lawmakers in 2023 will take effect
Several new laws passed by Michigan lawmakers in 2023 will take effect on Tuesday, Feb 13, 2023Making use of the first combined Democratic majority in the state House,...
![Legal Consequences of Rescheduling Marijuana – 2024](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Read-the-rest-here-Legal-Consequences-of-Rescheduling-Marijuana-Jan-2024.jpg)
Legal Consequences of Rescheduling Marijuana – 2024
Legal Consequences of Rescheduling Marijuana Jan 2024 a report from the Congressional Research Service.
![Scientists Discover The Reason Cannabis Causes The Munchies](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Scientists-have-identified-what-happens-in-the-brain-after-using-cannabis-that-causes-the-munchies-a-new-federally-funded-study-shows.jpg)
Scientists Discover The Reason Cannabis Causes The Munchies
For the first time, scientists have uncovered the precise neurological impacts of cannabis use that give rise to the phenomenon famously referred to as the "munchies,"...
![Maker of CBD products asks court to decide](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/US-Supreme-Court-Building.-02.jpg)
Maker of CBD products asks court to decide
The Petitions of the Week column highlights a selection of cert petitions recently filed in the Supreme Court. A list of all petitions we’re watching is available here....
![Transcription of the 1789 Joint Resolution of Congress Proposing 12 Amendments to the U.S. Constitution](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Komorn-Law-Best-Legal-Defense-in-Michigan-Bill-of-Rights.jpg)
Transcription of the 1789 Joint Resolution of Congress Proposing 12 Amendments to the U.S. Constitution
This information was taken from archives.gov. One should assume it is factual... but assuming information is a fact is a perilous assumption. Here is what you paid...
![New laws for 2024 – Buckle Up](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/2024-Buckle-Up.jpg)
New laws for 2024 – Buckle Up
States nationwide will welcome the upcoming year with the implementation of laws tackling crucial matters such as gun violence, book bans, and the introduction of...
![Biden Issues More Cannabis Pardons but…](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Ha-Ha-Ha-says-Joe-Biden-as-he-laughs-1080x630.jpg)
Biden Issues More Cannabis Pardons but…
Joe Biden has extended pardons for individuals charged with simple cannabis possession and use, yet disappointingly, he has refrained from granting clemency to those...
![Working With and Not Against, IRS Revenue Code 280E](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/IRS-280E.jpg)
Working With and Not Against, IRS Revenue Code 280E
Cannabis operators face IRS Revenue Code 280E restrictions, but smart tax planning and strategies allow entrepreneurs to mitigate its impact on their business.Komorn...
![Department of Attorney General Prepares for MLEAC Accreditation](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/MLEAC-Accredited-Class.jpg)
Department of Attorney General Prepares for MLEAC Accreditation
LANSING – The Michigan Department of Attorney General (DAG) recently welcomed a team of assessors from the Michigan Law Enforcement Accreditation Commission (MLEAC)....
![Oklahoma’s wild marijuana market is about to shrivel](https://komornlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Oklahoma-Weed-Riders.jpg)
Oklahoma’s wild marijuana market is about to shrivel
The world's weed market, once booming with nearly 14,000 licensed medical marijuana businesses at its peak, has experienced a steady decline since Oklahoma voters...