Michigan Court of Appeals Opinion – Crime Definition

Published Michigan Court of Appeals Opinion

Docket No(s) 362161
Lower Court Docket No(s) 2021-000966-FC
Hood, J.

“Crimes are supposed to be defined by the legislature, not by clever prosecutors riffing on equivocal language.”

[*1] “[C]rimes are supposed to be defined by the legislature, not by clever prosecutors riffing on equivocal language.” Dubin v United States, 599 US ___, ___; 143 S Ct 1557, 1572; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (2023) (quotation marks and citation omitted).

At issue here is the equivocal (subject to two or more interpretations and usually used to mislead or confuse) language of the reckless driving statute, MCL 257.626, which prohibits “operat[ing] a vehicle . . . in willful or wanton disregard for the safety of persons or property . . . .” MCL 257.626(2).

The traditional, narrow understanding and application of this statute is that it criminalizes driving in a reckless manner. The prosecution’s novel, expansive reading of this statute would also criminalize the decision to drive a vehicle that is not appropriately maintained due to the risk of potential mechanical failure.

Under this novel prosecution theory, a jury convicted defendant Timothy John Otto for reckless driving causing death, MCL 257.626(4).

The prosecution’s theory was that Otto failed to maintain the truck he was driving and that failure made him criminally liable under MCL 257.626(4)when the truck’s brakes failed while he was driving it, causing a wreck that resulted in a child’s death.

On appeal, Otto argues that he was denied effective assistance of counsel because his trial counsel failed to move to dismiss the reckless-driving charge when the facts of this case— failing to maintain a vehicle and then operating the poorly maintained vehicle—cannot support a [*2] conviction under MCL 257.626(4)1 

We agree. The text and context of MCL 257.626(4), and more broadly the Motor Vehicle Act, MCL 257.1 et seq., do not support the boundless interpretation underpinning the prosecution’s theory and Otto’s conviction.

We vacate his conviction. To hold otherwise would be to allow the prosecution—not the Legislature—to criminalize a wide array of commonplace conduct (such as failing to check your brakes, driving on old tires, and driving on empty) that the Legislature did not intend to outlaw.

FAQ

What is conviction vacated mean?

When a sentence is vacated: It legally annuls the conviction. Vacating a criminal sentence means removing that conviction from a person’s record. The record will then appear as if the person was never charged and convicted of a crime.

Why would a sentence be vacated?

Someone who has their conviction vacated are released from custody under certain conditions, such as a plea bargain being breached, proof of ineffective counsel, court bias, or another similar factor that might have impacted the outcome of the original trial.

Is vacating the same as dismissing?

‘Vacating’ or ‘setting aside’ is used when referring to nullifying a specific judgment from the judge (in this case, a guilty or ‘no contest’ judgment).

‘Dismissing’ applies to the entire case. It means that the case is thrown out for reasons other than its factual merits.

Does vacated mean innocent?

Winning the motion to vacate doesn’t mean that this is the end of the matter. The conviction or sentence is canceled as if it never existed, but the court doesn’t close your case. Instead, the prosecutor then decides whether to drop or pursue the original charges.

More Posts

How Much Does It Cost To Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney?

How Much Does It Cost To Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney?

Don't do the crime - if you can't pay the price.Average Flat Fees. Some criminal defense attorneys charge a flat fee for certain types of cases, instead of billing by the hour. This may or may not include filing fees, motions, fees, etc. Flat fees include: DUI/DWI –...

read more
How Much Does It Cost To Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney?

What do you do when you are pulled over for suspected DUI?

If you are pulled over for suspected drunk driving you are probably going to be arrested. The less you say - the better off you are in the long run. If you find yourself being pulled over for suspected DUI, ensure you pull over safely to the roadside, maintain a...

read more
Michigan Problem-Solving Courts Granted Nearly $19 Million

Michigan Problem-Solving Courts Granted Nearly $19 Million

"Data show these programs strengthen communities by reducing crime, boosting employment"LANSING, MI, October 24, 2024 (Substance Abuse Prevention Month) – The Michigan Supreme Court announces that the State Court Administrative Office (SCAO) has awarded $18,823,910...

read more
Michigan House Bill 5451 of 2024

Michigan House Bill 5451 of 2024

Michigan House Bill 5451 of 2024: A Step Toward "Safer Communities"Michigan House Bill 5451, introduced by Representative Sharon MacDonell in February 2024, aims to enhance firearm safety in homes with children. The bill mandates that the Department of Health and...

read more
Michigan House Bill 5451 of 2024

Michigan House Bill 5450 of 2024

Step by StepMichigan House Bill 5450 of 2024 is a bill that was introduced by Representative Sharon MacDonell on February 14, 2024. The bill was referred to the House Committee on Education and was reported with a recommendation with a substitute on May 14, 2024. The...

read more
Trump plans – How does Cannabis Business fit in?

Trump plans – How does Cannabis Business fit in?

You work hard. Now get ready to work harder to prepare to give more.President Biden's administration has proposed the reclassification of marijuana from a Schedule I controlled substance to a Schedule III drug, which recognizes its medical benefits. This significant...

read more
When Can Police Take Your Dash Cam?

When Can Police Take Your Dash Cam?

You work hard. Now get ready to work harder to prepare to give more.In Michigan, police can take your dashcam footage in specific situations, primarily when they believe it could serve as evidence in a criminal investigation. Michigan law permits officers to seize...

read more
When Can Police Confiscate Your Drone in Michigan?

When Can Police Confiscate Your Drone in Michigan?

Someone asked us... Can the police take my drone?As we have seen ... They can charge, arrest you and take your stuff for whatever they want.  You'll have to fight it out in court to get it back.In Michigan, the police can confiscate your drone under certain...

read more
People who are going to need a Lawyer – November 12, 2024

People who are going to need a Lawyer – November 12, 2024

People who are going to need a LawyerMan so drunk field sobriety tests were ‘too dangerous’ sentenced to life in prison for repeated DWI convictions‘Several terabytes’: Diddy prosecutors shed light on ‘voluminous’ discovery, including iCloud accounts and dozens of...

read more
Michael Komorn-Criminal Defense Attorney

About Your Attorney

Attorney Michael Komorn

Categories

Other Topics

Driving Under the Influence

Michigan

Your Rights

Michigan Court of Appeals

Law Firm VIctories

Share This