Search and Seizure – Consent or Plain view

KOMORN LAW

STATE and FEDERAL
Aggressive Legal Defense
All Criminal Allegations / DUI / Drugs
Since 1993

The Fourth Amendment was established to protect individuals from unreasonable searches and seizures, yet there are exceptions.

In Michigan, understanding the concepts of search and seizure, particularly regarding consent and plain view, is crucial for both law enforcement and citizens.

The Fourth Amendment protects individuals from unreasonable searches and seizures, but there are specific circumstances under which law enforcement can legally conduct a search without a warrant.

Search and Seizure Basics

Search and seizure refers to the process by which police officers can investigate a person’s property or belongings to find evidence of a crime.

Under the Fourth Amendment, any search must typically be supported by probable cause and conducted with a warrant.

However, two significant exceptions to this rule are consent searches and plain view seizures.

Consent Searches

Consent occurs when an individual voluntarily agrees to allow law enforcement officers to conduct a search. It is essential that this consent is given freely without coercion or intimidation.

In Michigan, if someone consents to a search of their home or vehicle, anything discovered during that search can be used as evidence in court.

This means if you invite police into your home and they find illegal substances or weapons during their investigation, that evidence can lead to criminal charges against you.

You might as well invite the devil in.

Plain View Doctrine

On the other hand, the plain view doctrine allows officers to seize evidence without a warrant if it is clearly visible while they are in a lawful position.

For example, if police are conducting an investigation outside your house for unrelated reasons (such as responding to noise complaints) and they see illegal items through an open window or door, they can legally seize those items without needing your permission.

The key difference here lies in how the police come across the evidence:

Consent requires permission from the individual being searched while plain view relies on what officers observe from their legal vantage point.

So keep your shades closed and your doors locked. You do not have to answer the door when the police or anybody come knocking.

Understanding these concepts not only empowers individuals regarding their rights but also highlights how crucial it is for law enforcement agencies to operate within legal boundaries when conducting searches. 

Knowing your rights when it comes to search and seizure—especially concerning consent versus plain view—can make all the difference in protecting yourself legally in Michigan.

For more details about the laws follow these links

 

Case Example: Search and Seizure – Consent – Plain view

Defendant moved to suppress coffee filters seized from a detached garage suspected of being the site of a methamphetamine manufacturing operation, that motion should have been allowed because the officers lacked consent to search and did not lawfully seize the coffee filters.

“In 2015, police officers arrested defendant, Michael Brian McJunkin, after responding to reported suspicious activity at a house in Battle Creek. When the police arrived, they noticed the smell of ammonia permeating from a detached garage and suspected methamphetamine (meth) manufacturing. The officers later discovered an active ‘one-pot’ meth laboratory and coffee filters containing ground up pseudoephedrine, a primary component in meth manufacturing. … Because we hold that the officers lacked consent to search and did not lawfully seize the coffee filters, we reverse.

“The parties agree that the officers did not have a warrant to search Wightman’s garage or the Explorer. McJunkin challenges the trial court’s conclusion that the search and seizure was legally justified under the consent and plain-view exceptions to the warrant requirement.

“We hold that the trial court clearly erred by ruling that Wightman freely and unequivocally consented to the search of his garage because the ruling was based on factual findings that were not supported by the evidence.

“Based on these errors, we conclude that the totality of the circumstances did not support a finding that the officers had consent to search the garage. As discussed, to establish the consent exception to the warrant requirement, evidence must show that the officers received consent that ‘is unequivocal, specific, and freely and intelligently given.’ … The evidentiary hearing disclosed no consent to search the garage that meets any of those criteria and, therefore, we reverse the trial court’s decision.

“For these reasons, the trial court erred by ruling that the consent and plain-view exceptions to the Fourth Amendment warrant requirements applied to the officers’ seizure of evidence from McJunkin’s vehicle.”

Read the court opinion (PDF).

Read the dissent (PDF).

Defend Your Future with Michigan’s Top Criminal Defense Attorney

Your rights and freedom are too important to leave to chance.

Facing Criminal Charges?

When you’re caught in the turmoil of criminal charges, every moment counts. The anxiety of potential jail time, hefty fines, and a tarnished reputation can be overwhelming. You may feel lost and unsure about where to turn for help.

The Consequences of Inaction

The stakes are high. A conviction can lead to long-lasting repercussions—affecting your job, relationships, and even your future opportunities. Without a strong defense, you risk losing everything you’ve worked hard for. Don’t let fear dictate your fate.

Expert Legal Representation

Our Michigan Top Criminal Defense Attorney is here to provide the expertise and support you need during this challenging time. With years of experience in navigating the complexities of criminal law, we craft personalized defense strategies tailored specifically for your case.

Why Choose Us?

Proven Track Record: Our attorney has successfully defended countless clients against various charges, earning a reputation for excellence in the courtroom.

Personalized Approach: We understand that every case is unique; we take the time to listen and build a defense strategy that fits your specific situation.

Your Advocate: We will fight tirelessly on your behalf, ensuring that your rights are protected every step of the way.

Your Freedom Is Our Priority

Attorney Michael Komorn

Attorney Michael Komorn

State / Federal Legal Defense

With extensive experience in criminal legal defense since 1993 from pre-arrest, District, Circuit, Appeals, Supreme and the Federal court systems.

KOMORN LAW (248) 357-2550

Disclaimer: This article provides a general overview, or opinions and does not substitute for legal advice.  As with any law it can change or be modified and research should be done before you rely on any information provided on the internet. Although we make all attempts to link relevant laws these laws can often be gray and corrupted to fit a narrative. Anyone charged with any alleged crime should consult an attorney for specific legal guidance. Articles may be 3rd party or contain opinions and information that do not reflect the current stance of Komorn Law.

Michigan Laws

The Right to a Jury Trial

The Right to a Jury Trial

When facing criminal charges you have the right to have a trial by jury. The justice system will offer you the right to a jury trial. It's just a matter if you can afford that right. A jury trial with an attorney that is not a public defender can be costly. If you...

read more
Can Police Lie To You?

Can Police Lie To You?

Police are allowed to lie to you. One might believe that if you ask an undercover cop if they are a police officer they have to tell you. That’s not true. Police can and will lie to you. It's legal for cops to lie The Police may legally lie, bluff, mislead and...

read more
Driving Under The Influence Penalties in Michigan

Driving Under The Influence Penalties in Michigan

Prescription drugs, medical marijuana, recreational cannabis, alcohol and more are considered to influence you in a way the law deems a crime.  Therefore you can be charged with operating a motor vehicle or driving under the influence and here are your possible...

read more
Things You Should Know About Boating and Drinking

Things You Should Know About Boating and Drinking

Boating and Drinking When boating and you're the captain - drink all you want and if you're driving - drink as much as you can because it's hot out there. Just make sure it's non alcoholic because nothing but a boatload of trouble comes with being arrested for...

read more
Michigan Gun Laws and CPL Requirements

Michigan Gun Laws and CPL Requirements

Concealed Pistol License Requirements An outline of requirements for those who want to obtain a Michigan Concealed Pistol License. A. State Requirements An applicant for a Michigan CPL must: 1. Be at least 21 years of age. 2. Be a citizen of the United States or an...

read more
Is Michigan an open carry gun state?

Is Michigan an open carry gun state?

Michigan is an open carry state. There is no law that says it is illegal to do so. The Michigan State Police legal update describes Michigan’s open carry  law as follows: In Michigan, it is legal for a person to carry a firearm in public as long as the person is...

read more
Medical Marijuana, Gun Ownership, and CPLs in Michigan

Medical Marijuana, Gun Ownership, and CPLs in Michigan

It is a complex and changing area of law. We know that federal law (18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(3)) makes it a felony for an “unlawful user of … any controlled substance” to “possess … any firearm or ammunition.” Marijuana is classified as a Schedule I controlled substance, so...

read more
US court upholds ban on selling guns to marijuana card holders

US court upholds ban on selling guns to marijuana card holders

SAN FRANCISCO — A federal ban on the sale of guns to medical marijuana card holders does not violate the Second Amendment, a federal appeals court said Wednesday. The ruling by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals applies to the nine Western states that fall under...

read more
Michael Komorn-Criminal Defense Attorney

About Your Attorney

Attorney Michael Komorn

Categories

Other Topics

Driving Under the Influence

No Results Found

The page you requested could not be found. Try refining your search, or use the navigation above to locate the post.

Michigan

Your Rights

Michigan Court of Appeals

Law Firm VIctories

Share This