Your Past Charges Could Affect Decisions for New Charges

Michigan Court of Appeals – PEOPLE v. JAMES THOMAS MASON, JR.

Jail vs Probation

In People v. James Thomas Mason, Jr., the Michigan Court of Appeals dealt with whether the district court could reasonably depart from the usual “no jail, no probation” presumption for a non-serious misdemeanor conviction, which in this case was driving with a suspended license (DWLS).

The district court sentenced Mason to a 93-day jail term, reasoning that his past offenses indicated a high risk of repeat offenses (recidivism), risk to public safety, and limited potential for rehabilitation.

Mason challenged the sentence, arguing it was harsher than necessary, given that DWLS is generally not considered a serious misdemeanor under Michigan law.

The district court justified its departure by pointing to Mason’s history of drunk driving and other recent charges, including domestic violence.

However, Mason argued that the sentencing was unfairly influenced by a local policy that often imposed jail or probation for similar cases, suggesting a lack of individualized consideration. In his appeal, Mason requested that if resentencing were ordered, a different judge should oversee it to avoid any perceived bias.

Attorney Michael Komorn

Attorney Michael Komorn

State / Federal Legal Defense

With extensive experience in criminal legal defense since 1993 from pre-arrest, District, Circuit, Appeals, Supreme and the Federal court systems.

KOMORN LAW (248) 357-2550

The Michigan Court of Appeals upheld the district court’s decision, finding no abuse of discretion.

The appellate court ruled that the sentence was justified given Mason’s history and that there was no clear evidence of a rigid local policy affecting the court’s sentencing choice. The court also stated that the district court adequately recorded its reasoning, supporting the sentence’s proportionality to the offense and the defendant’s background.

This case thus highlights the balance between standard sentencing guidelines and individualized sentencing based on a defendant’s criminal history.

For more detailed information, you can refer to the PDF here.

Michigan COA Opinion – Mason

Disclaimer: This article provides a general overview and does not substitute for legal advice.  As with any law it can change or be modified and research should be done before you rely on any information provided on the internet. Although we make all attempts to link relevant laws these laws can often be gray and corrupted to fit a narrative. Anyone charged with any alleged crime should consult an attorney for specific legal guidance.

Michigan Laws

Criminal Law FAQs – Probation Violations

Criminal Law FAQs – Probation Violations

Michigan Criminal Laws FAQs Theft CrimesAccording to Michigan State Law (Michigan Compiled Laws - MCL), a Probation Violation occurs when a person who has been sentenced to probation fails to comply with the terms and conditions of their probation order. These terms...

read more
Criminal Law FAQs – Theft Crimes

Criminal Law FAQs – Theft Crimes

Michigan Criminal Laws FAQs Theft CrimesAccording to Michigan State Law (Michigan Compiled Laws - MCL), Theft Crimes generally involve the unlawful taking of someone else's property with the intent to deprive them of it, either permanently or for a significant period....

read more
Criminal Law FAQs – Domestic Violence

Criminal Law FAQs – Domestic Violence

Michigan Criminal Laws FAQs Domestic ViolenceAccording to Michigan State Law, Domestic Violence is not a standalone criminal offense but rather a designation applied to certain crimes when the victim is a "spouse or former spouse, an individual with whom the person...

read more
Criminal Law FAQs – Assault and Battery

Criminal Law FAQs – Assault and Battery

Michigan Criminal Laws FAQs Assault and BatteryAccording to Michigan State Law, Assault and Battery are distinct but often related offenses. There isn't one single statute that explicitly defines both terms together. Instead, their definitions have evolved through...

read more
Criminal Law FAQs – Marijuana Offenses

Criminal Law FAQs – Marijuana Offenses

Michigan Criminal Laws FAQs Marijuana OffensesFAQ 1: Is recreational marijuana legal in Michigan? Answer: Yes, recreational marijuana is legal for adults 21 and over in Michigan. However, there are restrictions on possession, use in public places, and driving under...

read more
Criminal Sexual Conduct (CSC) – Michigan

Criminal Sexual Conduct (CSC) – Michigan

Criminal Sexual Conduct (CSC) in Michigan: Definitions, Penalties, and Legal References.Criminal Sexual Conduct (CSC) is a set of laws in Michigan that define and penalize various forms of sexual offenses. These laws are categorized into four degrees, with each degree...

read more
What Are Your Rights Before And After Arrest?

What Are Your Rights Before And After Arrest?

What are your rights before and after arrest?Generally, police require a search warrant to lawfully enter any private premises or to search electronic devices such as your phone or computer. If the police do not possess a search warrant, you are under no obligation to...

read more
Michael Komorn-Criminal Defense Attorney

About Your Attorney

Attorney Michael Komorn

Categories

Disclaimer: Please remember that the information provided in these legal tips is for educational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. Laws are subject to change, and interpretations can vary. While we strive for accuracy, legal information can be complex and may not apply to your specific situation. Reading this information does not establish an attorney-client relationship. It is crucial to consult with a qualified attorney to discuss the specific facts of your case before taking any action or making any decisions.

Other Topics

Driving Under the Influence

Michigan

Your Rights

Michigan Court of Appeals

Law Firm VIctories

Share This